Google Switches Off AI and Search for K-12 Student Accounts by Default as NYC Mayor Mamdani Pushes Back
By Lisa F. Keith

Google will switch off its Gemini AI tools and Google Search by default for K-12 student accounts, a policy announced Nov. 3 that leaves schools choosing between AI features built into Search or no Search access at all for students. The move has drawn sharp criticism from New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and parent advocates, even as Google softened one of its most contested points. Under the plan, four products (Gemini, Gemini Notebook, Gemini in Classroom and Google Search) will stay off for student accounts until a school administrator turns them on. A district that takes no action would leave all four off. Chris Phillips, Google’s vice president and general manager for education, said in a blog post that the company is responding to schools asking for more say over how students use artificial intelligence. Google has not set a firm start date. It says it will share details with schools in the coming months, and Education Week reports that Phillips expects the changes to begin early next year. The sticking point is Search. Phillips told The New York Times that Search and AI are “deeply integrated,” so a school that bans AI outright would also lose Search for student accounts, and students would see a message from their school saying it is unavailable. After the backlash, Google clarified on X that administrators can enable Search, Gemini and Gemini Notebook separately, meaning a district can turn on Search without the Gemini products. But enabling Search still brings AI Overviews and AI Mode with it, and Google has not announced a school version of Search without AI features. Mamdani responded on Bluesky, accusing Google of using its monopoly power to push AI into public schools. “No corporation should have the power to dictate how we teach our children,” he wrote. New York City had already taken a cautious line. In early September, NYC Public Schools announced a one-year pause on student-facing AI tools for elementary and middle school students. Los Angeles Unified made a similar move shortly afterward, restricting AI tools for students districtwide. In Washington, Sens. Richard Blumenthal and Josh Hawley wrote to Google in October asking why AI features had been made the default on school devices. Their letter noted that more than 150 million students worldwide use Google Classroom. The dispute builds on an August decision by Google to turn on its Gemini chatbot by default for many K-12 students. Until then, Gemini had been limited to users 18 and older, and the change set off an outcry. School leaders in New York are weighing the tradeoffs. Rich Calkins, superintendent of the Pocantico Hills Central School District, said he is deeply wary of any company that would box districts in over a feature that could harm students. His district’s technology director, Alana Winnick, said Gemini is the only major AI chatbot that meets New York’s student data privacy and security laws, which leaves few options for children under 13. She added that she does not believe the youngest learners should be using it. Parent group Schools Beyond Screens, which has pushed for screen-time limits and AI pauses in districts this year, urged school leaders to resist Google and move away from its tools. Others see a benefit. Erin Mote, CEO of the nonprofit InnovateEDU, said turning AI off by default shows trust in educators’ judgment, though she acknowledged that many people depend on Search. Her group recently released a model policy calling for generative AI to be disabled by default in pre-K through fifth grade. Google says it is also adding Guided Learning features to Search for student accounts, designed to walk students through problems step by step instead of handing over answers. Phillips has framed the goal as giving school leaders control and confidence to use AI in classrooms as they see fit. Critics say it puts schools in a bind: Search with AI, or no Search at all. For administrators, the decision lands in the middle of the school year: which tools each age group gets, and how to rework lessons if Search is switched off. With more than 150 million students on Google Classroom, a change to default settings carries weight far beyond one product menu. Details of the rollout are expected in the coming months, and districts will have to decide how to respond before the changes take effect.